Why Avoiding Freelancers is Costing Retailers More Than They Think
Partners
December 29, 2025

Why Avoiding Freelancers is Costing Retailers More Than They Think

Series: Flexible Staffing Management - Part 1

Retailers operate in a structurally tight labor market. According to Eurostat figures, the Netherlands had approximately 4.1% - the highest vacancy rate in the EU in the third quarter of 2025. Many retail positions are simply unfilled.

This tightness affects all sectors, but retail stands out. Research by SEO Economic Research shows that 84% of Dutch retailers have faced staff shortages in recent years. Especially larger stores feel this pressure daily.

There's a clear solution to fill this gap: flexible deployment of freelancers. Yet many retailers rarely use this option. The DBA Act creates uncertainty and prevents organizations from deploying flexible personnel when needed.

In this three-part series "Flexible Staffing Management", we examine these assumptions. We make the DBA Act understandable and show how retailers can remain agile year-round without unnecessary risks.

Why Retailers Avoid Freelancers

The number of self-employed in Dutch retail is remarkably low. Supermarkets, department stores, drugstores, and household or recreational goods stores are among the sectors with the fewest freelancers.

This is remarkable because staff shortages are significant. Yet many retailers deliberately choose not to use freelancers. Concerns about compliance and outdated assumptions play a major role.

The DBA Act in Brief

The DBA Act (Self-Employment Deregulation Act) was introduced in 2016 to combat false self-employment. False self-employment occurs when someone is hired as a freelancer but actually works as a regular employee.

The introduction caused much uncertainty. Employers became cautious, freelancers dropped out, and flexibility came under pressure. After implementation, an enforcement moratorium followed. The Tax Authority hardly checked unless there were deliberate violations.

Since 2025, this moratorium has been lifted. With the prospect of back payments and fines, some retailers have since preferred to avoid any form of freelance deployment.

Important to emphasize: the DBA Act is not intended to make self-employment impossible. The law specifically protects people who wrongly work as freelancers while entitled to employee protection.

Deploying freelancers is therefore possible - provided you separate real risks from assumptions and set up the right structures.

Doubts About Freelancer Professionalism

Another frequently heard concern: are freelancers reliable enough? What if someone doesn't show up? Or doesn't have the right level?

These concerns are understandable. Managers don't want extra stress or risk on the shop floor. At the same time, they're often based on an outdated image.

There are now platforms with carefully selected, experienced freelancers who are used to working in retail. Temper, MANUS integration partner, is an example. These professionals show up, deliver quality, and know the pace of the shop floor.

The Hidden Costs of a Rigid Personnel Model

Sticking to only permanent employees or temp workers seems safe but often proves expensive.

Lost Revenue and Poor Service

Understaffing costs money. Long checkout wait times or empty shelves cause customers to leave. Every missed purchase and every disappointed customer impacts your bottom line.

Rising Labor Costs

Overtime adds up quickly. Especially during peak periods, surcharges increase and margins evaporate. Temp workers offer speed but bring extra costs.

Freelancers work differently. You only pay for the hours needed, without long-term obligations, secondary employment conditions, or complex termination processes.

Why Freelancers Actually Have Strategic Value

When deployed intelligently, freelancers strengthen your organization on multiple fronts:

Scalability

Freelancers move with demand. Extra deployment during peaks, fewer hours when it gets quieter. This keeps your staffing balanced with customer traffic.

Access to Specialized Knowledge

Through freelance platforms, you bring in targeted expertise. Think visual merchandising, logistics support, or temporary project roles. You get quality without long-term salary and training costs.

Protection of Your Permanent Team

Freelancers absorb peak pressure. This prevents burn-out and increases job satisfaction. Motivated employees deliver better service and stay longer.

Gallup research shows that schedule quality correlates with lower productivity and higher absenteeism. Good schedules are predictable, stable, and give employees influence. Freelancers help make this possible.

A Sustainable Talent Pool

Freelancers aren't a one-time solution. Build a fixed pool and you'll shorten onboarding time, increase quality, and give managers room for core tasks during busy periods. Experience and continuity reinforce each other.

Conclusion

Retailers work in one of Europe's tightest labor markets but often hold onto inflexible personnel models. The DBA Act, doubts about reliability, and lack of structure play a role in this.

This reluctance has a price. Rising costs, lost revenue, and overloaded teams lurk.

Freelancer risks are often overestimated. If you organize deployment compliantly and structurally, freelancers actually become a strategic advantage. They enable scaling, protect your permanent team, and provide room to innovate.

In part 2 of Flexible Staffing Management, we dive deeper into the DBA Act and show why retail is particularly sensitive to false self-employment.

Want to know now how MANUS WFM helps make flexibility manageable? Schedule a demo and discover what is possible.