Why Retailers Struggle with the DBA Act
Partners
January 5, 2026

Why Retailers Struggle with the DBA Act

Flexible Staffing in Retail - Part 2

Retailers in the Netherlands have relied on flexible staffing for years to handle peak periods and bring in specific expertise. Since the introduction of the DBA Act (Self-Employment Deregulation Act), this flexibility increasingly creates uncertainty.

The DBA Act aims to clarify when a freelancer is truly self-employed and when there's actually an employment relationship. The law was never intended to discourage self-employment, but the fear of mistakes and back payments causes some organizations to avoid freelancers altogether.

In this second part of the Rethinking Retail Staffing series, you'll learn why this uncertainty persists, how false self-employment is assessed, and why retail is particularly vulnerable to compliance issues.

What is the DBA Act?

The DBA Act came into effect in 2016 as a replacement for the VAR declaration. The goal: to provide clients and freelancers with a framework to jointly assess whether their collaboration truly constitutes self-employment.

According to the DBA Act, client and freelancer must determine whether the working relationship fits self-employment, or actually resembles a disguised employment for which payroll taxes and social premiums must be paid.

Why was the DBA Act introduced?

Tax collection is an important reason, but the DBA Act touches on broader questions about the structure of the Dutch labor market.

Critics point out that self-employment sometimes serves as a cover for situations where people are economically dependent on one client, without rights such as continued pay during illness, dismissal protection, or pension accrual.

Unions and various political parties also argue that the structural deployment of freelancers in permanent positions puts the labor market under pressure. More formal employment would provide stability and a better-financed social system.

Additionally, there's concern that the growing number of self-employed leads to inequality in competition and skewed employment conditions.

The end of an enforcement moratorium

After the introduction of the DBA Act, an enforcement moratorium applied for years. The Tax Authority hardly checked, unless there were clear indications of abuse.

This moratorium ended on January 1, 2025. Since then, organizations actually risk back payments when a freelance construction is still classified as employment.

If false self-employment is unintentional, payroll taxes can be imposed retroactively from January 1, 2025. If the construction is considered deliberate, the Tax Authority can go further back in time.

From 2026 onward, fines will also follow if clients cannot demonstrate that they actively take measures to prevent false self-employment.

This active enforcement makes organizations nervous. Where previously mainly existed, there is now a concrete financial risk.

How does the DBA Act determine if there's employment?

In its assessment, the law doesn't look at the title in the contract, but at daily practice. The core question: does someone work truly independently or does the situation resemble a regular employment?

The following questions play a role:

  • Does the freelancer determine their own working hours or does the client do that?
  • Does the client give substantive instructions about the work?
  • Does the duration of the assignment resemble employment?
  • Does the freelancer perform the same work as permanent employees?
  • Is the work a structural part of the organization?
  • May the freelancer be replaced?
  • Is the rate in line with the salary of employees?
  • Is the compensation fixed in advance and paid periodically?
  • Does the freelancer work for multiple clients?

No single criterion is decisive. The overall picture determines the outcome. Even an approved model agreement offers no certainty if daily practice doesn't align with it.

Does the VBAR Act provide more clarity?

In 2025, the VBAR Act (Employment Relationship Assessment Clarification Act) was proposed. This law should more explicitly establish assessment criteria and reduce dependence on case-by-case assessment.

A notable proposal is a presumption of employment with an hourly rate below a set threshold (currently €37 per hour). Below that threshold, the client must prove that true self-employment exists.

Supporters see this as protection for lower-paid workers. Opponents find it too simplistic. Many freelancers use strategic rates or trade autonomy for lower costs. Critics fear that legitimate entrepreneurs will be excluded, while uncertainty for higher rates persists.

In parallel, there's the proposal for the Self-Employed Persons Act, intended to better protect true entrepreneurs.

The Deliveroo case: how judges view this

The case around Deliveroo shows how judges assess false self-employment. Deliveroo started in 2015 with temporary employment contracts, but switched from 2018 to self-employed constructions for delivery workers.

Union FNV started a collective procedure. On March 24, 2023, the Supreme Court ruled that the delivery workers were employees.

Although delivery workers largely determined their own working hours and could sometimes be replaced, according to the judge this didn't outweigh other factors. They received wages, worked under authority, and structurally performed core activities of the company.

The totality of circumstances was decisive, not one single element.

Why are retailers particularly vulnerable?

Retail functions in practice often strongly resemble employment. That makes them vulnerable to reclassification under the DBA Act.

Consider a store that deploys a freelance cashier during the holidays. The store determines shifts, prescribes how customers are helped, provides work clothing, and expects presence during opening hours. This quickly looks like employment, regardless of the contract form.

The same applies to a freelance visual merchandiser who is paid hourly, works according to fixed instructions, and barely runs entrepreneurial risk.

What seems flexible often doesn't legally meet self-employment standards.

Operational consequences

The uncertainty inhibits decision-making. Hiring freelancers feels risky. Hiring permanent staff reduces flexibility and increases fixed costs.

The result: retailers postpone recruitment, don't scale up with rising demand, and respond more slowly to changes. At the same time, there's a chance that flexible workers switch to other sectors where there's more room.

How to reduce the risk of violating the DBA Act

Retailers can take measures to reduce risks and maintain flexibility. In our next article in this series, we'll go deeper into this.

For now, the following applies:

  • Carefully document work agreements
  • Act according to model agreements
  • Encourage freelancers to have multiple clients
  • Ensure transparency in daily practice

Specialized platforms that integrate with workforce management software also help with this. Our partner, Temper, is an example. They maintain clear boundaries to prevent false self-employment.

For instance, a freelancer may work a maximum of 660 hours per year for one client, and the majority have multiple customers. In ten years, no Temper freelancer has been classified as falsely self-employed.

Conclusion

Now that enforcement of the DBA Act is active, uncertainty poses a real risk. New legislation tries to create clarity, but for now, assessment remains customized. The Deliveroo ruling shows that a few characteristics of self-employment don't suffice if the overall picture points toward employment.

Flexible hiring remains possible, but requires careful setup and documentation. Solutions like Temper and MANUS WFM help organize this flexibility responsibly.

Want to know more about MANUS WFM or Temper? Contact us and discover what is possible.